Skip to content

Staff vs student AI use: a policy checklist

A free list of questions to help a district decide its rules for staff and student AI use. These are questions for your district to answer, not requirements. Adapt them to your board's procedures.

Download PDF

Not legal advice. This checklist is general information. Check your state's official guidance and law, and your district counsel, before adopting any policy.

Staff use

  1. 1. Disclosure

    When staff use AI to help write materials that go to students, families or the board, will they say so? How?

  2. 2. Approved tools

    Which AI tools are approved for staff use, and who keeps that list current?

  3. 3. Data privacy review

    Has each tool been checked against your state student data privacy law and your vendor contracts or data privacy agreements before staff use it?

  4. 4. Protected information

    What student or staff information must never be entered into an AI tool that has not been approved?

  5. 5. Human review of decisions

    When AI output informs a decision about a student (grades, placement, discipline or services), who reviews it, and how is that review recorded?

  6. 6. AI detection

    Will an AI detection result ever be used on its own to discipline a student or lower a grade? If not, what other evidence is required?

  7. 7. Bias and access

    How will staff check AI tools and outputs for bias and for access needs, including students with disabilities and English learners?

  8. 8. Training

    What training do staff complete before using approved tools, and how often is it refreshed?

  9. 9. Questions and problems

    Who answers staff questions, and how does someone report a problem with an AI tool?

Student use

  1. 10. Grade-level rules

    Which AI uses are allowed at each grade level or course, and where is that written down?

  2. 11. Assignment expectations

    How will teachers mark whether AI is allowed, allowed with limits, or not allowed on each assignment?

  3. 12. Student disclosure

    How do students show when and how they used AI, for example a note, a citation or a process log?

  4. 13. Checking AI output

    Are students expected to check AI output for accuracy and cite their sources?

  5. 14. Approved student tools

    Which tools may students use, and have those tools passed the same privacy review as staff tools?

  6. 15. Age limits and consent

    Do any tools have age limits or require parent consent under their terms of service or your state law?

  7. 16. Family notice

    How will families learn which AI tools are used and what choices they have, such as an opt-in or opt-out if your state or district provides one?

  8. 17. Academic integrity process

    How does the AI rule connect to your academic integrity and discipline policies, and what process does a student get if misuse is suspected?

  9. 18. Review cadence

    When will the district review these rules, including when your state issues new guidance or law?

How some states address these topics

Short notes from our state summaries. Read the official source for what it actually says, and check your own state on the map or with Compare.

Next steps

Get Navigating Education free

You're subscribing to Navigating Education, Dr. Matt Rhoads' free weekly newsletter on the science of learning, AI and practical teaching. It goes out Tuesdays. Each issue includes an AI Policy Tracker section.

Subscribe to Navigating Education

Free. Unsubscribe anytime. See our privacy page. Not legal advice.

Not legal advice. Check your state's official guidance and your district counsel. Checklist published November 2026.